There is something about a pirate story that already feels halfway to fantasy.

You have ships disappearing beyond the horizon, hidden islands, mutiny, treasure, storms that can kill an entire crew, and people deciding that regular society has entirely too many rules.

Add actual magic, curses, mythical creatures, assassins, enchanted seas, and women who have no intention of staying in the roles they were given, and things get even better.

These fantasy pirate books put women at the center of dangerous voyages in all kinds of ways. Some are captains. Some join pirate crews because the alternative is worse. Some are running from arranged marriages, family expectations, empires, or people who would very much like to kill them. A few stumble into the pirate life almost by accident and then discover they are much better suited to it than anyone expected.

There is romance in some of these, but this is not strictly a pirate-romance list. The real thread tying them together is women claiming a place on dangerous, magical seas—and usually causing at least a little trouble once they get there.

This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through one of these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

If you would rather bring the high seas to game night, I also have a list of pirate board games filled with treasure, ship battles, adventure, and betrayal.

Women Who Were Never Going to Stay Where They Were Put

These are the women who look at the life someone else has planned for them and decide the ocean sounds better.

Fable by Adrienne Young

Fable grew up knowing the sea could take everything from you.

After watching her mother die in a storm, she is abandoned by her powerful trader father on an island full of thieves. Four years later, she has one goal: get off the island, find him, and demand the place beside him that she believes she has earned.

She gets help from a young trader named West, but reaching her father is only the beginning. His enemies are still very much around, West is keeping secrets, and the Narrows are not exactly known for being forgiving.

Why it fits: Survival, dangerous seas, complicated family relationships, found crew, and a heroine determined to make her own place in a world that has already tried to throw her away.

Good fit for: Readers who like YA fantasy, seafaring adventure, family drama, and slow-burn romance.

The Assassin’s Curse by Cassandra Rose Clarke

Ananna’s parents have arranged for her to marry into another pirate clan.

Ananna has a different career plan: captain her own ship.

So she runs.

Unfortunately, the offended family responds to this rejection in the calm and reasonable manner you would expect from pirates and sends an assassin after her. When Ananna accidentally triggers a curse that binds her to that assassin, the two are forced to travel together while trying to figure out how to break it.

Why it fits: Pirate clans, curses, assassins, sea travel, and a heroine whose entire problem begins because she refuses to let other people decide what her life is going to look like.

Good fit for: Readers who want magic, adventure, reluctant allies, and a heroine with absolutely no interest in behaving herself.

The Sneaky Lass by Kennedy Sutton

Jane has already been a wife, widow, thief, and prostitute before she finds her way aboard the damaged brig Sneaky Lass.

There is one complication: the ship is taking on men.

Jane cuts her hair, steals some clothes, becomes Dixon Ables, and hopes nobody looks too closely.

What begins as another desperate escape slowly becomes something she did not expect to find aboard a pirate ship: a home. The longer Jane stays, the more attached she becomes to the crew—and the more dangerous it becomes if anyone discovers who she really is.

Why it fits: Disguise, survival, found family, life aboard a pirate ship, and a woman discovering that the place she was supposed to escape from might actually be where she belongs.

Good fit for: Readers who especially like the everyday life of a crew, found family, historical pirate atmosphere, and secret identities.

Pirate Captains, Legends & Women With Reputations

Some women are trying to get onto the ship.

These women already have the ship.

Daughter of the Pirate King by Tricia Levenseller

Seventeen-year-old pirate captain Alosa needs an ancient map.

Her solution is to deliberately let an enemy crew capture her so she can search their ship for it.

Which tells you quite a bit about Alosa.

The plan should be simple enough, except the enemy first mate, Riden, is much more observant than she would like—and inconveniently attractive while he is at it. Alosa, however, has a few secrets of her own.

Why it fits: A female pirate captain, hidden treasure, secret missions, enemy ships, banter, and a heroine who is usually at least three steps ahead of everyone around her.

Good fit for: Readers who want fast YA fantasy, romance, enemies-to-lovers energy, and a very confident heroine.

The Adventures of Amina al-Sirafi by Shannon Chakraborty

Amina al-Sirafi has already had the legendary pirate career.

She has survived dangerous rogues, merchant princes, several husbands, and an actual demon. Now she would very much like to stay retired with her family.

Naturally, somebody shows up with one last job.

A wealthy woman asks Amina to rescue the kidnapped daughter of one of her former crew members. The payment could secure her family’s future, and it gives Amina an excuse to gather her old crew for one more adventure.

Except this is fantasy, so “one more job” quickly develops supernatural complications.

Why it fits: A middle-aged female pirate legend, old crew reunions, demons, magical danger, treasure, family, and the deeply questionable decision to come out of retirement for one last adventure.

Good fit for: Readers who want adult fantasy, a more mature heroine, strong worldbuilding, humor, and a full-blown supernatural pirate adventure.

Tempest by Victoria Aveyard

Cat Rose has already lived two very different lives.

Once she was Lady Catrine Rose, trapped in a marriage inside the Meridian Empire. Now she is the Widow Rose, queen of a pirate tavern in the Lyrian Sea and determined to control what happens next.

Unfortunately, an empire has decided it would like its pirate republic back.

The Empire gives Cat an ugly choice: help them capture legendary pirate Valerian Kane—the man she once loved—or hang.

So, you know. No pressure.

The story moves between Cat’s past and present as war closes in around the Lyrian Sea and old loyalties become much harder to separate from old feelings.

Why it fits: Pirate republics, naval war, political intrigue, romance, betrayal, and a woman who has already escaped one version of her life and has no intention of surrendering the next one easily.

Good fit for: Readers who want adult fantasy, pirates versus empire, complicated romance, political stakes, and a stormier, more dramatic tone.

Magic in the Water, the Weather & the Ships

Because apparently regular storms were not dangerous enough.

Dark Water Daughter by H.M. Long

Mary Firth is a Stormsinger.

Her voice can calm hurricanes—or destroy entire fleets.

That would be an impressive talent under normal circumstances. In a world full of pirates who would very much like to control that power, it is also a problem.

Rather than become the servant of a deathless pirate lord, Mary offers her abilities to his rival in exchange for protection and help killing him. Meanwhile, a disgraced naval officer is pursuing her, spectral creatures called ghistings haunt forests and ship figureheads, and everybody seems to have their own revenge plan.

Why it fits: Magical storms, terrifying pirates, sentient-feeling ships, supernatural creatures, revenge, naval battles, and one of the most literal versions of “woman controlling the sea” on this entire list.

Good fit for: Readers who want darker adult fantasy, unusual magic, maritime worldbuilding, pirates, privateers, and big adventure.

These Sanguine Tides by E.S. Barrison

Leena Davies has hated pirates since childhood, when they took her eye and killed her father.

Then her brother gets himself into serious trouble, and paying his bail leaves Leena aboard the Sanguine Tortuga.

So now she is living among the very people she grew up despising.

The ship has magic, secrets, a captain with his own agenda, and growing whispers of rebellion below deck. Leena eventually has to decide where her loyalty actually lies—and whether becoming part of this world means becoming the thing she has always hated.

Why it fits: Revenge, magical ships, rebellion, divided loyalties, and a heroine forced to reconsider everything she believes about pirates.

Good fit for: Readers who like darker pirate stories, morally complicated characters, rebellion, and questions about who actually gets labeled the villain.

The Mermaid, the Witch, and the Sea by Maggie Tokuda-Hall

Flora survives aboard the pirate ship Dove by becoming Florian.

Keeping that identity means protection from the crew—and keeping emotional distance from everyone around her.

Then Flora meets Lady Evelyn Hasegawa, an imperial daughter being transported to an arranged marriage she desperately does not want.

Their connection complicates everything.

And this is not merely a pirate story with a little magic sprinkled on top. The world includes mermaids, witches, colonial power, slavery, identity, and a sea that feels like something much bigger than scenery.

Why it fits: Pirates, magic, mermaids, secret identities, rebellion, romance, and two people trying to escape the lives other people have chosen for them.

Good fit for: Readers who want YA fantasy with romance, queer characters, darker themes, and a magical world with political stakes.

Strange Seas, Treasure Hunts & Pirate Adventures

These lean harder into the pure adventure side of the list.

On These Black Sands by Vanessa Rasanen

Declan has spent years avoiding the island where the council gives the orders and the pirates obey.

Bad luck forces him back.

Then he hears about a dagger that might finally give him a way out of the life he has been trapped in.

There is just one complication.

A stowaway.

Because apparently pirate escape plans are never allowed to involve simply finding the thing and leaving.

Why it fits: Pirates, rebellion, dangerous islands, hidden objects, shifting loyalties, and characters trying to escape systems that have controlled them.

Good fit for: Readers who like pirate crews, adventure fantasy, romance, secrets, and series they can keep reading after the first book.

Tress of the Emerald Sea by Brandon Sanderson

Tress is not looking for adventure.

She likes her quiet island life and collecting cups.

Then Charlie leaves home, disaster follows, and Tress does something extremely unlike the person everyone thought she was: she goes after him.

That eventually puts her aboard a ship sailing seas made of deadly spores, surrounded by pirates and heading toward a Sorceress.

These are not ordinary oceans, either. In this world, even a drop of water hitting the wrong sea can become a very serious problem.

Why it fits: Pirates, bizarre magical seas, a reluctant heroine growing into adventure, a rescue mission, and some of the strangest ocean rules on this list.

Good fit for: Readers who want whimsical fantasy, fairy-tale energy, clever worldbuilding, and something lighter than the bloodier pirate books here.

Cinnamon and Gunpowder by Eli Brown

This one is the oddball on the list, and I mean that affectionately.

Pirate captain Mad Hannah Mabbot kidnaps renowned chef Owen Wedgwood and gives him a simple condition for staying alive: make her an excellent meal every Sunday.

On a pirate ship.

With pirate-ship ingredients.

While people are trying to kill them.

Owen begins improvising increasingly elaborate meals while gradually realizing that Mabbot may have more going on than simple piracy. She is being hunted by a privateer, someone aboard her ship may be sabotaging her, and her pursuit of the mysterious Brass Fox has a purpose Owen does not yet understand.

Why it fits: A formidable female pirate captain, sea battles, a strange crew, danger, adventure, and quite possibly the only pirate book where I am also concerned about what is for dinner.

Good fit for: Readers who want adult historical adventure, an unusual pirate story, eccentric characters, and something that does not feel like every other book on the list.

Final Thoughts

Pirate stories are already about people living outside the rules.

That gets even more interesting when the women in those stories are also pushing against the lives other people chose for them.

One refuses an arranged marriage because she wants her own ship. Another disguises herself just to get aboard one. One has already become a legendary pirate and would really prefer everyone stop dragging her back into supernatural nonsense. Another can literally control hurricanes with her voice.

And sometimes a woman just needs to cross a deadly magical sea full of pirates because the person she loves needs rescuing.

Reasonable.

Whether you want treasure hunts, curses, sea monsters, romance, mutiny, magical storms, found family, or women taking command of ships they were never supposed to have, there is plenty here to keep you at sea for a while.

And unlike an actual pirate voyage, you can stop whenever you want.

Probably.

If the romance and lighter fantasy on this list are more your speed, you can also explore my Fantasy Rom-Com Books for When You Want a Fun Escape.

Keep Exploring Fantasy Books:

• Fantasy and Paranormal Book Series to Binge
  From vampire romance and urban fantasy to witches, grim reapers and magical kingdoms, these fantasy and paranormal book series will keep you reading.
• 12 Books Like Narnia for Adults Who Still Check the Wardrobe
  If you still check the back of wardrobes just in case, these 12 adult fantasy novels are for you. Discover hidden worlds, magical books, secret doorways, and stories that bring back the wonder of childhood reading.
• Books That Capture the Vibes of What We Do in The Shadows
  If you can’t get enough of the quirky undead antics, dry humor, and unforgettable characters in What We Do in the Shadows, this book list serves up similar vibes in novel form. From supernatural comedy to offbeat vampire hijinks and darkly charming paranormal tales, these picks capture the humor and heart of weird-but-lovable creatures of the night. Perfect for fans who crave supernatural laughs, eccentric ensembles, and stories that don’t take the undead too seriously.