There’s something magical about December nights — the scent of pine, the soft glow of lights, and the quiet thrill of a mystery unfolding by the fire. But if your holiday reading taste leans more comfort and cocoa than crime and chaos, this list is for you.
These Christmas-themed mysteries mix festive settings with suspicious deaths, family secrets, and plenty of amateur sleuthing. Some are light and cozy, while others lean darker or more puzzle-heavy. Think Christmas lights and hot cocoa with a mystery to untangle—not necessarily a completely gentle read.
This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through one of my links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
The Knife Before Christmas by Kate Carlisle
Genre: Cozy Mystery | Small-Town Setting
Contractor Shannon Hammer finds herself investigating trouble during the holidays in Lighthouse Cove. This is a good pick if you enjoy amateur sleuths with practical skills, a familiar small-town cast, and Christmas festivities interrupted by a mystery.
The Knife Before Christmas
Everyone in town loves the hotel’s spirit, except the Garrisons’ children and their spouses, who are hum-bugged by the money being wasted on holiday cheer while their inheritance goes up the chimney.
Dying in a Winter Wonderland by Vicki Delany
Genre: Cozy Mystery | Holiday Village
In Rudolph, New York — a town that celebrates Christmas year-round — murder might be the only thing that can stop the sleigh bells. Vicki Delany keeps it sweet and suspenseful, with lighthearted humor and community spirit that feels like coming home.
Gavels, Tinsel and Murder by Victoria Tait
Genre: Cozy Mystery | British Setting
An antique shop and a bustling winter market set the scene for this holiday mystery. If you like British village settings, seasonal traditions, and clues tucked into everyday encounters, this one fits the bill.
Gavels, Tinsel and Murder (A Dotty Sayers Antique Mystery)
A charity ball. A dead guest. Can an amateur sleuth solve the case or will it ruin Christmas for ever?
It’s Beginning to Look a Lot Like Murder by Ann Stang
Genre: Cozy Mystery | Contemporary Small Town
Pine View’s Three Trees Festival provides a festive backdrop for secrets that threaten to disrupt the celebration. This one leans into small-town relationships and the complications that arise when people who know each other well start keeping things hidden.
It’s Beginning to Look a Lot Like Murder
Christmas in our small town of Pine View is a cozy season highlighted by the Three Trees Festival. Every house is ready for holiday visits with cookies and hot, yummy drinks. But this year instead of peace on earth and goodwill toward men, somebody has murder in mind.
The Christmas Jigsaw Murders by Alexandra Benedict
Genre: Cozy Mystery | Puzzle Mystery
A Christmas-themed jigsaw puzzle becomes part of a disturbing murder investigation in this twisty seasonal mystery. It’s a darker, more unsettling pick than a traditional cozy, but the puzzle-solving angle makes it a good fit for readers who like to piece together clues.
The Christmas Jigsaw Murders
Rest. In. Pieces.
On 1st of December, renowned puzzle setter, loner, and Christmas curmudgeon Edie O’Sullivan finds a hand-delivered present on her doorstep. Unwrapping it, she finds a jigsaw box and, inside, six jigsaw pieces.
The Mistletoe Mystery by Nita Prose
Genre: Cozy Mystery | Lighthearted
Hotel housekeeper Molly Gray returns for a holiday-themed caper featuring Secret Santas and small misunderstandings. Nita Prose blends humor, heart, and the gentle reminder that kindness is the best gift of all.
The Mistletoe Mystery
Molly Gray has always loved the holidays. When Molly was a child, her gran went to great lengths to make the season merry and bright, full of cherished traditions. The first few Christmases without Gran were hard on Molly.
Stalking Around the Christmas Tree by Jacqueline Frost
Genre: Cozy Mystery | Small-Town Series
A family-owned Christmas tree farm makes a fitting setting for this seasonal mystery. Alongside the sleuthing, there’s small-town romance and plenty of holiday activity, making it a lighter choice for readers who don’t want a grim crime story.
Stalking Around the Christmas Tree
For inn keeper Holly White, Christmas time in Mistletoe, Maine, is the ultimate holiday gift. Business at the Reindeer Games Inn is booming, her wedding to Sheriff Evan Gray is nearly here, and the annual parade is about to begin.
The Naughty List (Darcy Sweet Cozy Mystery #20) by K.J. Emrick
Genre: Cozy Mystery | Paranormal
Darcy Sweet’s ghostly helper returns in this holiday entry that’s full of goodwill, gentle humor, and just the right amount of supernatural sparkle.
The Naughty List
The ghost of a teenage girl… A catastrophic fire… And a devastating secret that shatters Darcy Sweet’s world.
It’s just another Christmas in Misty Hollow and it’s business as usual for Jon and Darcy with a disturbing mystery to solve.
The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year by Ally Carter
Genre: Cozy Mystery / Romantic Comedy
Two rival mystery writers arrive at an English estate for Christmas, only to find themselves caught up in a real-life mystery when their host, a famous author, disappears. Expect sharp banter, suspicious guests, and a little romance alongside the clues.
The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year
The bridge is out. The phones are down. And the most famous mystery writer in the world just disappeared out of a locked room two days before Christmas.
Murder at the Mayfair Hotel by C.J. Archer
Genre: Historical Cozy Mystery
For readers who love period settings, C.J. Archer offers old-world Christmas charm in a posh London hotel. Intrigue stays mild, elegance stays high — perfect with tea and shortbread.
Murder at the Mayfair Hotel
December 1899. After the death of her beloved grandmother, Cleopatra Fox moves into the luxury hotel owned by her estranged uncle in the hopes of putting hardship and loneliness behind her. But the poisoning of a guest on Christmas eve throws her new life, and the hotel, into chaos.
A Ruff Royal Christmas by Karen Schaler
Genre: Holiday Romance with Mystery Elements
A missing royal pup throws a wrench into the Christmas festivities, bringing a little mystery along with the romance and holiday cheer. This one’s for readers who prefer their seasonal sleuthing lighthearted, with plenty of animal-loving charm.
A Ruff Royal Christmas
Princess Ava’s perfectly planned Christmas Eve charity event erupts into chaos when she loses Stormy, the Queen’s mischievous new border collie. With Christmas fast approaching, Ava must team up with Justin, a laid-back American dog trainer who’s used to wrangling strays, not royal runaways.
Merry Merry Merry Murder (Cuddle Farm Mysteries) by Paty Jager
Genre: Cozy Mystery | Animal Lovers
Christmas crafts and therapy animals give this small-town mystery its holiday personality. It’s a gentler pick for readers who enjoy community relationships and a puzzle without a relentlessly grim atmosphere.
Merry Merry Merry Murder
In the close-knit town of Auburn, Oregon, Andi Clark’s therapy animals bring comfort to the community, especially during the holiday season. When a young girl seeks solace from Athena, Andi’s therapy dog, after witnessing an unsettling scene behind the sleigh, it marks the beginning of a much darker holiday.
✨ Why We Love Holiday Cozy Mysteries
Christmas mysteries have a way of making even a suspicious gathering feel festive. Some of these books stick to gentle small-town sleuthing, while others bring darker secrets or a little romantic tension. Either way, snow, holiday traditions, and a good puzzle make a pretty irresistible combination. And since a cozy mystery practically begs for something warm to sip, here’s a little hot chocolate treat for your next reading night.
So pour yourself some cocoa, light the tree, and curl up with one (or several) of these Christmas reads. And if you’re in the mood for something with sharper edges after all that cozy sleuthing, try my Christmas thrillers and suspenseful holiday mysteries next.
