Sometimes the scariest thing isn’t what’s lurking in the dark—it’s what’s unraveling in your mind.
fmg Glimmer Brow Definer
BENEFITS
• Shapes brows with perfect blendability.
• Retractable, swivel tip applicator
• Smudge-, transfer-, sweat-, and waterproof
• Rich pigments provide vivid, opaque color payoff
• Comes off easily with soap and water or makeup remover
Psychological horror messes with your sense of reality. These books don’t rely on gore or jump scares. Instead, they feed you paranoia, plant doubt, and leave you questioning every sentence. If you love unreliable narrators, identity breakdowns, creeping madness, and the literary equivalent of a mental spiral… you’re in the right place.
Here are some psychological horror books that will absolutely break your brain—in the best (and worst) way.
🌀 House of Leaves by Mark Z. Danielewski
A house with a hallway that shouldn’t exist. A documentary that doesn’t exist. A man obsessively documenting the people obsessed with it.
This cult classic is physically difficult to read: sideways text, footnotes within footnotes, mirror writing. The structure mirrors the madness. If you make it through, congrats—you’ve survived one of the most mentally disorienting horror novels ever written.
House of Leaves: The Remastered Full-Color Edition
”Simultaneously reads like a thriller and like a strange, dreamlike excursion into the subconscious.” —Michiko Kakutani, The New York Times
🪞 Come Closer by Sara Gran
A woman hears tapping in the walls. Then she starts forgetting things. Then someone dies.
Is Amanda being possessed by a demon… or is she simply going insane? This novel is chillingly spare, devastatingly intimate, and designed to make you question how much of your own behavior is really yours.
Come Closer
Demonic possession or psychic break? One of Esquire‘s Top 50 horror novels of all time delves deep into the terrifying consequences of losing control.
“A perfect horror novel.”—Paul Tremblay, author of The Cabin at the End of the World
🕳 The Cipher by Kathe Koja
There’s a hole in the floor of a storage closet. It doesn’t go anywhere, but it changes everything.
Dark, grimy, and grotesquely poetic, this cult favorite dives headfirst into obsession, decay, and identity annihilation. Warning: you will not come out clean.
🧠 I’m Thinking of Ending Things by Iain Reid
A road trip. A couple. A visit to meet the parents. A mounting dread.
This novel weaponizes ambiguity. You’ll spend most of the book wondering what’s wrong—and the final pages will leave your brain smoking. Psychological horror at its most cerebral.
I m Thinking of Ending Things: A Novel
240 Pages
“I’m Thinking of Ending Things is one of the best debut novels I’ve ever read. Iain Reid has crafted a tight, ferocious little book, with a persistent tenor of suspense that tightens and mounts toward its visionary, harrowing final pages” (Scott Heim, award-winning author of Mysterious Skin and We Disappear).
🧍♀️ You Were Made for This by Michelle Sacks
A seemingly perfect life in the Swedish countryside begins to curdle with gaslighting, obsession, and past trauma.
Told from multiple perspectives, this is a slow spiral into emotional and psychological collapse. Everyone is lying, and no one is safe.
You Were Made for This
A gripping page-turner for fans of The Woman in the Window and The Perfect Nanny, Michelle Sacks’s You Were Made For This provocatively explores the darkest sides of marriage, motherhood, and friendship.
🕯 The Elementals by Michael McDowell
A Southern Gothic masterpiece with ghosts, grief, and the slow burn of mental and emotional decay.
One of the creepiest parts? No one will talk about what’s wrong. And that psychological repression becomes more terrifying than the haunted house itself.
“The finest writer of paperback originals in America.” – Stephen King “Surely one of the most terrifying novels ever written.” – Poppy Z. Brite
“Beyond any trace of doubt, one of the best writers of horror in this or any other country.” – Peter Straub
🎭 The Shards by Bret Easton Ellis
A group of privileged teens in 1980s LA unravel as a serial killer stalks their periphery.
But is the narrator telling the truth? Or spinning a self-serving version of events? This novel is sprawling, narcissistic, and deeply unreliable—in all the right ways.
The Shards: A novel
A novel of sensational literary and psychological suspense from the best-selling author of Less Than Zero and American Psycho that tracks a group of privileged high school friends in a vibrantly fictionalized 1980s Los Angeles as a serial killer strikes across the city.
🧪 A Head Full of Ghosts by Paul Tremblay
A teenage girl is possibly possessed. Or she’s mentally ill. Or her family is exploiting her for a reality TV show.
Told by her younger sister years later, the story flickers between memory, trauma, media, and myth. Expect to lose your grip on what really happened.
Head Full of Ghosts, A
A chilling thriller that brilliantly blends psychological suspense and supernatural horror, reminiscent of Stephen King’s The Shining, Shirley Jackson’s The Haunting of Hill House, and William Peter Blatty’s The Exorcist.
🔮 Baby Teeth by Zoje Stage
A mother is convinced her young daughter is trying to kill her. Her husband thinks she’s paranoid.
This chilling, claustrophobic novel is a cat-and-mouse game between parent and child—except no one can leave the house. Unsettling, emotional, and disturbingly plausible.
Baby Teeth: A Novel
“Unnerving and unputdownable, Baby Teeth will get under your skin and keep you trapped in its chilling grip until the shocking conclusion.”―New York Times bestselling author Lisa Scottoline
🫣 Boy Parts by Eliza Clark
A provocative photographer spirals into self-destruction, obsession, and delusion.
Think: American Psycho with a female lead and a heavy dose of satire. It’s messy, unreliable, and violently psychological.
Boy Parts: A Novel
An incendiary debut novel from a brash new talent—a pitch-black comedy, both shocking and hilarious, which fearlessly explores sexuality and gender roles in the twenty-first century.
“Hallucinogenic, electric and sharp, Boy Parts is a whirlwind exploration of gender, class, and power.”—Jessica Andrews, author of Saltwater
🪓 Verity by Colleen Hoover
A struggling writer discovers a manuscript by a bestselling author that reveals terrifying secrets about her past.
Romantic thriller meets full-blown psychological horror in this twist-heavy, deeply disturbing tale of obsession and manipulation.
Verity
Whose truth is the lie? Stay up all night reading the sensational psychological thriller that has readers obsessed—soon to be a major motion picture—from the #1 New York Times bestselling author of Too Late and It Ends With Us.
🔁 Bonus Mentions (Because One Brain-Break Isn’t Enough)
- The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides – Twisty therapy sessions, silence, and a killer backstory.
- Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier – A classic psychological slow-burn that will have you second-guessing every glance and shadow.
- Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn – Not horror, but a masterclass in manipulation and narrative mind games.
- Anything by Shirley Jackson – Especially We Have Always Lived in the Castle or The Sundial.
The Sundial (Penguin Classics)
When the Halloran clan gathers at the family home for a funeral, no one is surprised when the somewhat peculiar Aunt Fanny wanders off into the secret garden. But then she returns to report an astonishing vision of an apocalypse from which only the Hallorans and their hangers-on will be spared, and the family finds itself engulfed in growing madness, fear, and violence as they prepare for a terrible new world.
💬 Ready to Lose Your Mind?
Psychological horror isn’t about monsters—it is the monster. These books will leave you unsteady, uncertain, and absolutely obsessed.
